Sunday, October 18, 2009

Unmarked Cars and Law "Enforcement"

When I lived in Missouri, I got a poll from the state highway patrol asking my views on unmarked cars. Now, as often as I've offered derision to this state, there are occasionally some great things that come out of the legislature, such as the "No call" list (which incidentally had more teeth than the federal law and generated the state quite a bit of revenue - kudos) and this survey.

It had me call into question exactly why I dislike unmarked cars. I finally boiled it down to being a question of prevention vs. enforcement. If you have an unmarked vehicle on the road, most drivers won't slow down, because they have no concern for getting caught. While certainly the one individual who's going faster than the herd of speeders might certainly be impacted by the ticket he gets from the unmarked vehicle, the impact this makes on a given day is relatively small. In fact, it's questionably legal for an officer to issue a ticket to a speeding driver if they're going about the same speed as the rest of traffic.

On the other hand, a vehicle all painted up with the agency in questions name, symbols and so forth, with lights atop and being very obvious will definitely slow down traffic wherever it is. As long as this vehicle is on the road, it is protecting the law by assuring that everyone around it is following it. The more of these vehicles on the road, the less people are likely to violate the law.

But this isn't law enforcement. Law enforcement is about enforcing the laws - catching as many violators as you can. In fact, if you maintain the mindset of doing your job by catching violators, it seems that it would be better for there to be more criminals, since the more there are, the more important the police officer is to society. It is in the interest of every police department, sherrif's office and highway patrol bureau that there be many criminals, lest they become unimportant.

It's like the network engineer's dilemma: If you do your job well and maintain a stable network, solving problems before they impact users, you have made yourself invisible, taken for granted. The only way technical operations staff, in general, can be seen is if they allow things to fail occasionally. Then they get to be heroes by fixing it.

Police only get to be heroes by catching criminals. Although it's in society's interest to have some sort of body reducing crime, Law Enforcement isn't it. Not only is it not their interest, it's not their mandate to prevent crime. I think there's a lot of confusion about this in minds of almost everyone involved. Police departments get more money to catch more criminals in the interest of reducing crime, and in the mean time our prisons are brimming with a greater percentage of our population than any other country on earth. Sure, we need a solution, but more law enforcement isn't it.

Thursday, November 20, 2008

Tending towards equilibrium?

I've been following discussions on markets and models and the like, not being concerned with money, so much as the way people think about systems. George Soros spends a lot of time talking about how financial markets don't naturally tend towards equilibrium.

I studied control systems in school. At one point I was even considering an advanced degree in stochastic systems - random response behavior. Independent of whether the model of the system is good or not, you can't negotiate on the math. One of the fundamental things we talked about is how the natural state of equilibrium would be disrupted by any change and what it would take for it establish a new equilibrium. If the system were overdamped, then it would eventually settle into a new steady state. If the system were underdamped, the oscillations would continue to increase and eventually the system blows up.

We've seen this happen in both markets and cultures, from the latest market crash to the fall of Rome. Occasionally some folks develop this romantic notion that lost cultures, religions, or lifeways may have some crucial knowledge or something important to teach us. I'm not so sure, although they serve as countless examples that things definitively do not tend towards equilibrium. The few lucky ones that last very long in anything resembling a steady state? Well, perhaps they do have something to tell us about cultural control mechanisms.

The notion that many social scientists, most economists, and all libertarians seem to subscribe to is that every "free market" social or economic system is, put in control theory terms, overdamped. One of the typical characteristics* of an overdamped system is that it has a very slow change response. You can see where this is going on the modern world: "Remove the damping effect in order to be more responsive to the rapidly changing world we live in."

So the super-system of the world control system tends towards movement from the cautious, conservative system which does tend towards equilibrium, to a more responsive, reckless, unstable system.


*This characteristic is typical for first-order feedback systems. Most social and economic feedback mechanisms are fairly (mathematically) simple in terms of how they influence the behavior of the markets or cultures. More advanced feedback mechanisms should theoretically be possible, but these systems are unlikely to spontaneously arise and I can only imagine how hard complex systems would be to institute if one were able to devise something like that.

Sunday, March 02, 2008

Transportation and consumerism

I've been thinking lately a lot about how the fall of public transit changed how people come by objects. Back in the day, you'd take the bus/trolley/train/whatever off to work or to the market or wherever you went if it wasn't a few blocks from home. You didn't buy heaps and piles of stuff because then you had to carry it all home. In your hands. No trunk to carry home all that bric-a-brac you don't really need.

When my mother went grocery shopping (she went once a month for a family of 6), she came home with probably 30 bags of groceries at a time. My friends with cars don't think twice about toting stuff around and most probably have hauled 10 times more than they should around in them. (Except those who are aware and concerned about fuel economy.) I feel pressure more and more to buy a car so that I, too, can tote stuff around and don't have to rely on other people. Everyone expects to be able to carry stuff and doesn't even think about it.


I wonder if the cartel that destroyed public transit in this country had any idea of the age of rampant consumerism they were ushering in by doing so. I'm beginning to think that has more to do with the *stuff* issues we contend with now than advertising or any other market push. People didn't just See the USA in their Chevrolet, they bought it and brought it home with them. I never thought about that before.

Friday, September 21, 2007

Burning Man and Gödel Numbers

So I was reading a particularly interesting section of Hofstadter's Gödel, Escher, Bach today on the way home from work. He got into an interesting discussion about "stepping out of the frame" and refuting someone's argument that computers couldn't do this but humans could. When he went on to talk about how Buddhists, artists, and mathematicians were always trying to accomplish this, it struck me as "how Burning Man". Of course, I've been relating a lot to that lately.

Then he went on to talk about how Galileo used a third party to create the impression of a "neutral third party" that wasn't really neutral because he was consistently agreeing with one of the two competing parties. Hofstadter pointed out that this character was only functional in reinforcing the argument for party he supported. Why was he so convincing? Because he gave the sense of stepping out of the frame of the argument and examining it from a position of disinterest.

Of course, this is sort of an illusion in that we can never step outside the frame of reality and sort of not since the reality we interact with is defined by how we frame it. It seems to me the entire point of this Burning Man exercise is an attempt to collectively reframe reality. Or at the very least step outside the structure and rules, in some way, that define who we are, in an effort to redefine who and what we, individually and collectively, are.

However, the implication of this which Hofstadter presented that I find most interesting is that once structuring or defining how "stepping out of the frame" is done, it can be incorporated into the system as a rule. This is the ongoing struggle that all artists and mathematicians must continue to wrestle with if they're any good. Of course, this kind of makes me laugh when I hear people whining about the awful theme just as much as I laugh when people are whining about how it's not as good as it used to be. That last one is particularly striking, considering that if it were the same as it used to be, then it would not be as good because what used to be is known, codified, documented, remembered and incorporated while the whole point of this exercise is to extend beyond that.

Which kind of brings me to my next curiosity... one of the things I noticed was that people have a lot of the same themes and "avant garde" ideas year after year. If you do it repeatedly is it avant garde? If you have it down to a science and know exactly what you're doing is it really stepping out of the frame? While I realize that exposure to really different stuff can help others sort of shake loose their own reality, if they've seen it, isn't it just becoming like, say, Monet and his haystacks - mass production on a smaller scale?


There are a couple of interesting current-day implications to this thread of logic I think are interesting. Not the least of which is how including an illusory neutral third party is more damaging to a disadvantaged disputant than having no third party at all. I suspect one of my old professors at Berkeley figured that out (only in not so mathematically structured terms) when she took her support away from mediation in conflict resolution situations. (Although there are some other serious flaws with that as well.)

But basically, the most troubling is the notion that the iterations and illusions of breaking out that we engage in to make ourselves feel better are not often doing us any good, as we follow models created by other "like minded" individuals around us.

Monday, May 28, 2007

Reality's death-grip

I've been trying rather hard to figure out what the difference is between "normal" people and people I consider my friends. There's always been some obvious gulf between mainstream and where I stand, but I have a lot of trouble naming it.

The ability to suspend disbelief is my current best approximation of what that difference is. I've met some people who don't even like fantasy movies like LotR, which I find unfathomable. But I think people who test what they're considering against their known understanding of reality I find uncomfortable. While I certainly respect a firm grip on reality, I find it interesting to be able to carry theoretical frameworks to their logical conclusions even though they could never be. Also, I've found that those who maintain that reality death-grip tend to be less open to accepting and trying new things, or worse, project their own pre-conceived notions on what they observe.

Then again, at the same time, I also find it uncomfortable when "disbelievable" things are lent a credibility they should not have, which is annoyingly common around Berkeley. I think some people's acceptance comes in some very black and white flavors.

Why do people have to be so serious about reality?

Thursday, April 26, 2007

Transgressions or Crossing Against the Light

There's an intersection near where I live that has a rather annoying signal pattern. Since it gives an explicit left turn consecutively to the eastbound then the westbound traffic, pedestrians wishing to cross on the north side are told to wait for the westbound traffic signal. Out of the hundreds of times I've crossed at that intersection, I think I've seen 3 cars turning north. What this means is it's a waste of time to wait for the signal to change.

I think it's interesting watching the varieties of reactions people have to the transgression of crossing against the signal when it's clearly foolish to wait. Some wait regardless; follow the rules. But most transgress - most break the rules and cross early. I've noticed different strategies that people employ.

Some boldly cross as soon as the signal changes for the eastbound, without a moment's hesitation. Often they carry an air of superiority or knowingness, particularly when there are others around that are more hesitant. They know the way of things and are eager to demonstrate that it's the wise course to break the rules.

Hesitation is common. I myself hesitate. Why? I want to be polite for those 3 cars I've seen in my tenure, because theirs truly is the right of way. But if they choose not to exercise it, I won't let the moment go to waste. Others lack confidence. Not everyone seems so ready to believe that there's no danger in crossing. They timidly cross. Others hesitate as if participating in some sort of internal struggle, then race across, as if to avoid being caught in transgression.

I think understanding transgression is important for understanding change. Following and breaking written or unwritten rules and the strategies used for their variable employment and dismissal is what defines culture drift and change. The pattern of the traffic signal near my house is not likely to change any time soon, just as many cultural constructs that seem outdated don't change. It's a small thing and the effort to change the function of the signal would be greater than the cost of the violations. The transgressions will continue unabated.

Sunday, April 22, 2007

Making a difference?

So I left the possibility for chat in one of my online communities open late at night while I was working on other things. Random people could chat, and at odd hours, this usually means someone from a different part of the globe.

So this older gentleman from Ankara sends me a message. He introduces himself and asks a few polite questions. He admits that his English is poor. I reply to his questions, ask a few of my own, then check out his profile to try to get a sense of where he's going. Apparently, unlike other fellows who are trying to score an American bride or just plain score, he's got loftier goals. He is apparently trying to make the world a better place.

Apparently, he feels that by making friends across the world he can do something to stop the "blood and tears" of war by being friends. Initially, a the super-jaded part of me is saying "While noble, that's pretty naive. What kind of difference can you make doing that?"

Then a realization settles over me that it's actually pretty profound. He has come to a general public place, not somewhere that's one of those closed communities that only talks to themselves, like so many of our "activist" sites have come to be. He's trying to make a personal connection. To individuals.

It makes me go on to think... what if 10 people from Islamic countries reached out and made friends with 10 people each from the US? Just random people. It really would change the world, at least a little bit.

Of course, it means that they have to make the effort in our language. Imagine what would happen if all of the sudden we all could understand each other without that.