Burning Man and Gödel Numbers
So I was reading a particularly interesting section of Hofstadter's Gödel, Escher, Bach today on the way home from work. He got into an interesting discussion about "stepping out of the frame" and refuting someone's argument that computers couldn't do this but humans could. When he went on to talk about how Buddhists, artists, and mathematicians were always trying to accomplish this, it struck me as "how Burning Man". Of course, I've been relating a lot to that lately.
Then he went on to talk about how Galileo used a third party to create the impression of a "neutral third party" that wasn't really neutral because he was consistently agreeing with one of the two competing parties. Hofstadter pointed out that this character was only functional in reinforcing the argument for party he supported. Why was he so convincing? Because he gave the sense of stepping out of the frame of the argument and examining it from a position of disinterest.
Of course, this is sort of an illusion in that we can never step outside the frame of reality and sort of not since the reality we interact with is defined by how we frame it. It seems to me the entire point of this Burning Man exercise is an attempt to collectively reframe reality. Or at the very least step outside the structure and rules, in some way, that define who we are, in an effort to redefine who and what we, individually and collectively, are.
However, the implication of this which Hofstadter presented that I find most interesting is that once structuring or defining how "stepping out of the frame" is done, it can be incorporated into the system as a rule. This is the ongoing struggle that all artists and mathematicians must continue to wrestle with if they're any good. Of course, this kind of makes me laugh when I hear people whining about the awful theme just as much as I laugh when people are whining about how it's not as good as it used to be. That last one is particularly striking, considering that if it were the same as it used to be, then it would not be as good because what used to be is known, codified, documented, remembered and incorporated while the whole point of this exercise is to extend beyond that.
Which kind of brings me to my next curiosity... one of the things I noticed was that people have a lot of the same themes and "avant garde" ideas year after year. If you do it repeatedly is it avant garde? If you have it down to a science and know exactly what you're doing is it really stepping out of the frame? While I realize that exposure to really different stuff can help others sort of shake loose their own reality, if they've seen it, isn't it just becoming like, say, Monet and his haystacks - mass production on a smaller scale?
There are a couple of interesting current-day implications to this thread of logic I think are interesting. Not the least of which is how including an illusory neutral third party is more damaging to a disadvantaged disputant than having no third party at all. I suspect one of my old professors at Berkeley figured that out (only in not so mathematically structured terms) when she took her support away from mediation in conflict resolution situations. (Although there are some other serious flaws with that as well.)
But basically, the most troubling is the notion that the iterations and illusions of breaking out that we engage in to make ourselves feel better are not often doing us any good, as we follow models created by other "like minded" individuals around us.
No comments:
Post a Comment