Tending towards equilibrium?
I've been following discussions on markets and models and the like, not being concerned with money, so much as the way people think about systems. George Soros spends a lot of time talking about how financial markets don't naturally tend towards equilibrium.
I studied control systems in school. At one point I was even considering an advanced degree in stochastic systems - random response behavior. Independent of whether the model of the system is good or not, you can't negotiate on the math. One of the fundamental things we talked about is how the natural state of equilibrium would be disrupted by any change and what it would take for it establish a new equilibrium. If the system were overdamped, then it would eventually settle into a new steady state. If the system were underdamped, the oscillations would continue to increase and eventually the system blows up.
We've seen this happen in both markets and cultures, from the latest market crash to the fall of Rome. Occasionally some folks develop this romantic notion that lost cultures, religions, or lifeways may have some crucial knowledge or something important to teach us. I'm not so sure, although they serve as countless examples that things definitively do not tend towards equilibrium. The few lucky ones that last very long in anything resembling a steady state? Well, perhaps they do have something to tell us about cultural control mechanisms.
The notion that many social scientists, most economists, and all libertarians seem to subscribe to is that every "free market" social or economic system is, put in control theory terms, overdamped. One of the typical characteristics* of an overdamped system is that it has a very slow change response. You can see where this is going on the modern world: "Remove the damping effect in order to be more responsive to the rapidly changing world we live in."
So the super-system of the world control system tends towards movement from the cautious, conservative system which does tend towards equilibrium, to a more responsive, reckless, unstable system.
*This characteristic is typical for first-order feedback systems. Most social and economic feedback mechanisms are fairly (mathematically) simple in terms of how they influence the behavior of the markets or cultures. More advanced feedback mechanisms should theoretically be possible, but these systems are unlikely to spontaneously arise and I can only imagine how hard complex systems would be to institute if one were able to devise something like that.
No comments:
Post a Comment